Archive for July 10, 2012

Annan’s attack on GCC and his defense of Russia

July 10, 2012

Annan’s attack on GCC and his defense of Russia.

By Abdul Rahman al-Rashed

Abdul Rahman al-Rashed

When Kofi Annan was appointed as a special U.N. envoy to Syria, I had hastened to warn about him. I claimed that Annan was brought in to prolong the tenure of Assad regime. I said that this was the last comic act in the theater of the Arab League and the United Nations.

Annan quit the U.N. after serving as its secretary-general with a scandal involving his son who had allegedly played a role in the oil-for-food program with Iraq when economic sanctions were in place against the regime of Saddam Hussein.

After three months of futile efforts and more bloodshed, it was clear that Annan was virtually a dummy that was brought in to serve the interests of a group that wanted to split the international unity and save the Assad regime by quelling the Syrian revolution.

Now, things have become intolerable as far as this envoy was concerned to the extent where Annan lost his patience with the UAE Foreign Minister Sheikh Abdullah bin Zayed Al Nahyan when he criticized Annan. The minister said that it is disgraceful that the man who was entrusted to act as the U.N.’s envoy in Syria was absent at a major meeting on Syria in which representatives of nearly half of the governments in the world participated.

After this, Annan came out heavily against Al Nahyan in his latest interview with French daily Le Monde. In the interview, which showed his disposition clearly, Annan blamed Gulf states such as UAE, Saudi Arabia and Qatar in clear terms. He said, “Very few things are said about other countries (meaning Gulf states) that send arms and money and weigh on the situation on the ground!” By this, he meant that they are arming the revolutionaries.

Annan was not at all bothered about putting into practice important elements of his initiative. He never called for prosecuting the Syrian regime which failed to stop military operations and pull back troops from cities. On the contrary, he asked the world to leave the people of Syria at the mercy of the oppressor.

In the interview, Annan ignored the world sentiment and presented his own arguments focusing on the criticism of Russia. “Focusing on Russia would disturb Russians too much. What surprised me was that most of the comments were focused on Russia while Iran was spoken about on a lesser degree!”

Singling out Russia in criticism was because it is a permanent member of the U.N. Security Council. As for Iran, it has no value as far as international decision-making was concerned. Had Russia not opposed, China also would not have been doing it because international intervention was inevitable to stop the genocide perpetrated by the Syrian regime forces since last summer. It was because of Russia and not because of Iran that the tragedy is going on in Syria where thousands of innocent people have already been killed and 1.5 million displaced.

Annan also called on inviting Iran to the negotiating table about the future of Syria. This would have been acceptable if the objective was to convince the Assad regime to carry out reforms. But we have passed this stage and now the only way to find a peaceful solution is to put an end to the regime without allowing it to do more harm. In this, Iran won’t play a positive role. Iran may have a future role if it was found later to be cooperating with the alternative government.

Annan then backed Russia’s supportive position to Syria by refusing to intervene and stop the genocide by the forces of Assad. He said that Russia and China were deceived in Libya in the name of a “responsibility to protect” civilians. He said that was then turned into a process to change the Qaddafi regime. Annan is now forgetting the Libyan situation that warranted an international decision. The forces of Qaddafi had been carrying out the same operations of killing, destruction and the displacement of hundreds of thousands of people just like what Assad is now doing in Syria. Qaddafi was not governing a safe country. On the contrary, Libya was in a bloodbath that had to be stopped to protect the civilians. Had the Security Council resolution not been there during that night, the Qaddafi forces would have destroyed the besieged city of Benghazi.

An international intervention in Syria has become imperative to protect the Syrian people as well as the region, in addition to stop dismantling the region and prevent the emergence of terrorist groups to fill the vacuum following Assad regime’s collapse.

(The writer is the General Manager of Al Arabiya. The article was published in the Saudi-based Arab News on July 10, 2012)

Iran reaffirms full support for Annan’s Syria peace plan

July 10, 2012

Iran reaffirms full support for Annan’s Syria peace plan.

U.N. Syria peace envoy Kofi Annan did not spell out the agreement or say what kind of involvement he saw for Iran in resolving the Syrian crisis. (Reuters)

U.N. Syria peace envoy Kofi Annan did not spell out the agreement or say what kind of involvement he saw for Iran in resolving the Syrian crisis. (Reuters)

Iran on Tuesday reaffirmed its full support for international envoy Kofi Annan’s peace plan aimed at ending the Syria crisis, saying that the plan should be fully implemented to restore stability.

As many as 28 people have been killed by the fire of Syrian forces on Tuesday, Al Arabiya reported citing Syrian activists.

“We expect that Mr Annan will continue his efforts to bring about stability and peace in Syria and the region,” Foreign Minister Ali Akbar Salehi said at a joint news conference with the U.N. and Arab league envoy.

Annan arrived in Iran after talks with embattled Syrian President Bashar al-Assad on Monday and following a “Friends of Syria” meeting in Geneva last month to which Iran, Damascus’s staunchest regional ally, was not invited.

Tehran was excluded from the Geneva talks — which the Islamic republic dubbed “unsuccessful” — following US and EU objections.

The gathering in Switzerland agreed a plan for a political transition in Syria which did not make an explicit call for Assad to quit, although the West and the opposition made clear it saw no role for him in a unity government.

Annan, a former U.N. chief, on Tuesday reiterated his wish that Iran be involved in a solution to the crisis.

Accusing Iran of supporting Assad

The West and the Syrian opposition accuse Tehran of supporting the regime in Damascus militarily, a charge it vehemently denies.

“There is a risk that the situation in Syrian gets out of hand and spreads to the region,” Annan told reporters.

“Iran can play a positive role,” he said, adding he would continue to work with the Iranian leadership to resolve the crisis which monitors say has cost more than 17,000 lives.

Salehi reiterated that “Iran is part of the solution” in Syria, and criticized Arab and Western countries, without naming names, for excluding it.

But he also hailed Annan’s “neutrality” on the issue.

Before flying to Tehran, Annan said he had agreed on a new “approach” with Assad to stop the violence, which activists say has killed more than 17,000 people since the conflict began in March 2011.

Annan did not spell out the agreement or say what kind of involvement he saw for Iran in resolving the crisis. Anti-regime fighters dismissed any role for Iran in a plan they and some experts say has little hope of succeeding, The Associated Press reported.

Annan peace plan

Annan presented a peace plan earlier this year, but it has been deeply troubled from the start.

Government forces and rebels have widely disregarded a cease-fire that was to begin in April, and spreading violence has kept nearly 300 U.N. observers monitoring the truce stuck in their hotels in Syria.

After a two-hour meeting with Assad on Monday, Annan said the men had agreed on “an approach” to stop the violence, and that the diplomat would share it with the armed opposition.

“I also stressed the importance of moving ahead with a political dialogue which the president accepts,” Annan said.

Last week, Annan acknowledged that international efforts to find a political solution for Syria had failed and called for a greater role for Iran, saying Tehran “should be part of the solution.”

Syria’s uprising began with political protests and has since evolved into an armed insurgency, with scores of rebels groups across the country regularly clashing with government troops and attacking their convoys and checkpoints.

On Monday, the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights said its total death toll for the conflict is more than 17,000 people. That includes 11,900 civilians, nearly 900 military defectors and about 4,350 government soldiers.

The group relies on a network of activists on the ground who document deaths and right violations by talking to witnesses and medics and watching amateur videos.

Another group, the Local Coordination Committees (LCC), says more than 14,800 civilians and rebel fighters have been killed. The group does not report military deaths.

The Syrian government says more than 4,000 soldiers have been killed. It does not provide numbers for civilian dead and bars most media from working in the country.

In a rare interview with the foreign press broadcast Sunday, Assad said most of those killed in Syria were government supporters.

He also told German public broadcaster ARD that the United States is complicit in the killings, saying it backs the opposition he says is made up of armed gangs and terrorists.

Asked if he feared that he might share the fate of [Muammar] Qaddafi, who was killed shortly after his capture, Assad said:

“Describing what happened to al-Qaddafi, this is savage, this is crime. Whatever he did, whatever he was, nobody in the world can accept what happened, to kill somebody like this.”

“What happened to Mubarak is different. It’s a trial. Any citizen, when he watches a trial on TV — he would think that he won’t to be in that position. The answer is: Don’t do like him. Don’t do like him,” the 46-year-old leader said, according to Reuters.

“But to be scared, you have to compare. Do we have something in common? It’s a completely different situation … You cannot compare. You cannot feel scared — maybe feel sorry or a pity whatever.”

Ongoing clashes

Inside Syria, activists reported shelling by government forces and clashes with rebels in opposition areas throughout the country Monday. The LCC told Al Arabiya that at least 51 people were killed nationwide.

In May, rebels succeeded in pushing the army from the city center, although government forces kept the city surrounded with checkpoints.

Video shot in the city Monday showed a dead man lying on a sidewalk with his head in a pool of blood and four other bodies in a pickup truck.

Another video from northwestern Syria showed at least five dead government soldiers lying in the street, one with an apparent bullet hole in his forehead.

The death tolls and authenticity of the video could not be independently verified.

Also Monday, Russia, the Assad regime’s biggest arms supplier, said it would not sign any new weapons contracts with Syria until the conflict calms down.

But Vyacheslav Dzirkaln, deputy chief of the Russian military and technical cooperation agency, told Russian news agencies that Russia will fulfill all previous contracts.

Russian President Vladimir Putin said Moscow is still committed to the Annan peace plan, adding that the Syrian government and opposition groups should be “forced” to start a dialogue.