WarSclerotic

The Iran – Israel |War

Archive for May 28, 2010

« WarSclerotic home page
Newer Entries »

An Unheard-of Number of 800 Scud Missiles Ready to Fire

May 28, 2010

DEBKA.

SCUD-D missile

A single Patriot anti-missile battery was stationed Monday, May 24, at Morag in northwestern Poland, less than 40 miles from the Russian naval and air bases in the enclave of Kaliningrad. A hundred US troops were attached to the site for training Polish soldiers in its use.
Although the Patriot was a pale relic of the missile shield President George W. Bush planned for East Europe, it drew deep frowns in Moscow. Seekers of comments were referred to the Russian foreign ministry spokesman Andrei Nesterenko‘s statement of a month ago that such unilateral moves by the US cannot be left unaddressed.
Russian pundits specializing in US-Russian relations took a somewhat sharper tone, describing the move as a deliberate attempt to undermine Russian-American relations.
What would the Russians have said if the United States, or any foreign power, had parked not a single air defense Patriot, but 800 Scud-D surface-to-surface strike missiles with a 700-1,000-mile range, capable of carrying chemical or nuclear warheads – not 40 miles, but less than 16 miles from their territory?
That is exactly what Syrian President Bashar Assad has done, DEBKA-Net-Weekly‘s military sources reveal here. They are not part of the Syrian Army’s array of missiles for deterring an Israeli invasion of Lebanon and Syria, but parked on the Syrian-Lebanese border, painted in Hizballah battle colors and assigned Hizballah store serial numbers. Each battery has its own Hizballah unit, attached after learning how to operate them at Syrian bases for the past half year.

Unparalleled bonanza for Hizballah

Wednesday and Thursday, May 26-27, tensions shot up several notches when Beirut lined up behind Damascus and Hizballah and boosted its army units on the South Lebanese-Israel border “against any emergency” and the Syrian army placed all its units on war preparedness, ordering its ballistic missile units to switch to firing positions.
Israel, which ended its homeland defense exercise against missile attack Thursday, May 27, prepared to join Greece next week in a joint naval and aerial exercise for practicing in-flight refueling.
(For details, see also HOT POINTS below)

The stages of the buildup approaching its peak were progressively covered in DEBKA-Net-Weekly and DEBKAfile‘s reports. Even so, all our experts were astounded to learn that the unheard-of number of 800 Scuds had been assigned to Hizballah, a fact never disclosed until now.
The entire Scud D behemoth is now positioned ready for removal into Lebanon at one and-a-half hour’s notice from Assad’s green light. The Hizballah crews have been taught to launch them on the move at predetermined Israeli targets.
Syria, Iran and Hizballah have made military history – and that is why the Middle East is teetering on the brink of war. Four armies were on combat readiness Wednesday, May 26 after the Lebanese Army lined up behind Syria and Hizballah against Israel’s Defense Forces and Syrian ballistic missiles were placed in firing positions.
Never has any army, least of all a terrorist organization like the Shiite Hizballah, ever commanded so many surface-to-surface strike missiles and held them ready to fire on a neighbor’s cities.
By comparison, North Korea’s arsenal is also estimated at around 800 ballistic missiles. They include long-range systems which could one day strike South Korea and Japan. But even that rogue nation has never placed those weapons in firing position at points abutting the borders of South Korea and Japan.

Deeply ingrained collaboration with North Korea

And how would the strategic position of the 100,000 US troops fighting in Afghanistan be affected if the Pakistani government were to suddenly and covertly let Taliban have 800 Ghauri surface-to-surface missiles (similar to the Scud D) for firing at Kabul from its South and North Waziristan sanctuaries?
This scenario would sound absurdly unreal anywhere in the world – even in trouble spots. Yet, in the Middle East, it is a cruel reality.
The Scud concentration on the Syrian-Lebanese border came off Syrian military industry production lines, our military sources report. Their manufacture is based on North Korean technology, diagrams and licenses. They are in fact a Syrian adaptation of the North Korean Rodong-1 missile, whose 1,000-mile range brings Japan within firing distance.
This missile is essentially a hybrid: Its Isayev 9D21 engine was upgraded with the help of Russia’s Makeyev OKB industries as well as China and Ukraine, while the new TEL uses an Italian Iveco truck chassis and an Austrian crane.
Pyongyang’s Rodong program was itself largely financed by Iran in return for permission to reproduce it as the Shahab-3 ballistic missile.
Iranian-Syrian military collaboration with North Korea is thus deeply ingrained with Hizballah now brought into the equation for the first time.
Yet for reasons outlined in the next article, no Western power has hindered the coming together of these hugely destabilizing elements.

A Strategic (or Guilty) Secret
All Hands Join to Hide Number of Scuds – 800 (!) – Bound for Hizballah
Barack Obama

For ten days, the US and Israel improbably joined forces with Syria, Lebanon and South Korea for a mighty effort to conceal the mammoth figure of 800 Scud missiles held ready for Hizballah in custom-built Syrian bases a 15-20-minute drive from the Lebanese border.
This effort was exhaustive enough to magic away the only media reference; an item in the Japanese Sankei Shimbun of Sunday, May 23; vanished overnight from the paper’s Web site and the Internet.
But DEBKA-Net-Weekly managed to pin it down. Here is the quote:

North Korea has agreed to Syria’s shipment of long-range Scud missiles to the militant Lebanese Shiite group Hezbollah. Syria is reportedly obliged to receive approval from North Korea the technology provider when handing over missiles to a third party. Citing unidentified sources, Japan says the North Korean embassy in Syria said it has “no intention to object to Syria’s transfer of Scud missiles to Hezbollah.” We speculate that the model Syria plans to provide the Lebanese militant group with is the Scud D with a range of 700 kilometers.”

The Japanese item included the disclosure that the Syrian president needed North Korean approval for transferring the Scud Ds to Hizballah. Given the structure of the ruling regime in Pyongyang, the handover would have necessitated a nod from Kim Jong-il in person.

Red faces in Washington

All the parties concerned one way or another found the Japanese disclosure embarrassing enough to kill it.
The United States, for one, DEBKA-Net-Weekly‘s Washington and military report, was not prepared to own up to the failure of its every effort (going back to the Clinton and Bush administrations) to curb the massive proliferation of nuclear and missile weapons technology originating in North Korea – most damagingly to the Middle East. Worse still, for the first time, the North Korean ruler actually authorized their transfer to a militia officially listed by the UN and the US as a terrorist organization.
As long as this level of nuclear and other dangerous weapon proliferation goes on unchecked, questions must be asked about the point of the “bold and pragmatic” program President Barack Obama submitted to the Washington summit of 47 world leaders on April 13, asking for their commitment to eliminate or lock down their nuclear materials within four years.
With US Secretary of State Hillary Clinton in Beijing this week (May 23-25) for discussions centering Iran’s nuclear program and a bid for Chinese support for UN sanctions, Washington could not afford to let it be known that the world’s top nuclear violator Kim Jong-Il had more leverage over war and peace in the Middle East than any other Asian, or even European, leader.
There might also have been quite a few red faces if the presence of 800 Scud D missiles under Hizballah’s hand had been discovered during Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri‘s first White House visit Monday, May 24. It would have signaled the collapse of the Obama administration’s policy of wooing Assad and exposed a US intelligence fiasco, to boot.

How would Netanyahu and Barak explain how it happened?

In any case, no sooner was Hariri home to Beirut when he lined up behind Syria and Hizballah in boosting his southern units against “a war emergency,” despite his promise to the US president to try and abate rising war tensions.
Israeli leaders would also have been seriously discomfited by this discovery (see the separate item on the debate over Israel’s restraint in the missile threat), because the public would demand answers to at least three questions:
1. How did North Korea, a country far from Israeli consciousness, manage to grab a leading role in the schemes for its destruction for the second time in three years? The first time was in 2007, when Pyongyang helped construct the Syrian plutonium reactor at A-Zur which Israel destroyed before it was up.
2. How could Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Defense Minister Ehud Barak let 800 Scud missiles pile up on the Syrian-Lebanese border for no purpose other than to destroy Israel’s cities without stepping in to destroy them? That many Scuds imperils Israel’s very existence no less than the plutonium Syria would have produced had the Israeli Air Force not bombed its reactor in 2007.
3. Hizballah’s leader Hassan Nasrallah makes no secret of his plan to devastate Israel’s population centers with hundreds of missiles and rockets while at the same time fighting to capture sections of northern Israel. (See Issue no. 430 of DNW from January 22 – Iran-Hizballah Mark out Patches of Northern Israel for Capture). So is the Netanyahu government sitting on its hands and letting it happen?
Lebanon’s leaders President Michel Suleiman and the prime minister had an obvious interest in keeping the 800 Scuds hidden from sight. Their discovery would have shown them up as the stooges of Syrian president Bashar Assad and Iran’s surrogate Hizballah who are free to manipulate Lebanon according to their interests.

Assad capitalizes on the secrecy for buck-passing on the impending war

As for Bashar Assad, who built up the Scud stockpile, he is exploiting the missile controversy to pass the buck for the flare-up of hostilities he is engineering to the United States and Israel.
In an interview with the Rome newspaper La Repubblica on Monday, May 24, the Syrian ruler said the United States had lost its influence in the Middle East by failing to contribute to regional peace. In his view, US President Barack Obama had “raised hopes” in the region but failed to follow through with substantive peace moves.
Assad also boasted about a new world order which, he said, had cut the United States down in the world by refusing to wait for roles to be handed out by Washington. He was referring to the bloc formed by Turkey, Brazil, Syria and Iran and sponsored on the outside by Russia and aiming a side swipe at Obama’s White House welcome for Lebanese Prime Minister Saad Hariri, by showing that Damascus calls the shots in Lebanon – not Washington.
By keeping the 800 Scud D stock poised for handover to Hizballah dark, the United States and Israel played into Assad’s hands and let him get away with engineering the elements of an impending Middle East war while pinning them blame on them.

Categories: Uncategorized

Comments: Be the first to comment

A US nuclear submarine crosses into Strait of Hormuz

May 28, 2010

DEBKAfile, Political Analysis, Espionage, Terrorism, Security.

DEBKAfile Special Report May 27, 2010, 7:45 PM (GMT+02:00)

Tags: Iran Strait of Hormuz US nuclear sub

US nuclear-submarine in Persian Gulf waters

Tehran reports that an Iranian naval patrol Thursday, May 27, detected a US nuclear submarine sailing through the strategic Strait of Hormuz, through which most of the oil produced by Persian Gulfstates passes on its way to world markets. DEBKAfile‘s Iranian sources report Tehran has placed its navy and army on high alert.

Western intelligence and naval sources confirm that a nuclear-armed American submarine has in fact entered the Persian Gulf. This confirms DEBKAfile‘s report of May 20 that the Obama administration had decided to boost US military strength in the Mediterranean and Persian Gulf regions in the short term with an extra air and naval strike forces and 6,000 Marine and sea combatants. Carrier Strike Group 10, headed by the USS Harry S. Truman aircraft carrier, was due to sail out of the US Navy base at Norfolk, VirginiaFriday, May 21.

On arrival, it was to raise the number of US carriers off Iranian shores to two.
Thursday’s arrival of a US nuclear submarine also ties in with the currently rising military tensions along Israel’s borders with Syria and Lebanon.

Up until now, President Barack Obama kept just one aircraft carrier stationed off the coast ofIran, the USS Dwight D. Eisenhower in the Arabian Sea, in pursuit of his policy of diplomatic engagement with Tehran.

Categories: Uncategorized

Comments: Be the first to comment

UN asks for agreement on nuclear disarmament

May 28, 2010

UN asks for agreement on nuclear disarmament.

2010-05-28 06:30:00

With one day left before a month-long nuclear review conference ends Friday, UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon urged the participants to agree on nuclear disarmament as expected by the world.

‘There is too much at stake for the conference to repeat the failure of 2005,’ Ban said in a letter to the Nuclear Non-proliferation Treaty meeting at UN headquarters in New York.

Ban urged the parties to break deadlocks over nuclear disarmament and non-proliferation efforts. The every-five-year conference ended in disaster in 2005 when the United States led the charge against Iran’s nuclear activities and the conference ended without a statement.

The 189 NPT signatories were to issue a final declaration Friday, which in its draft form calls for a timeline for the elimination of all nuclear weapons in the possession of the world’s five recognized nuclear powers: the United States, Russia, China, France and Britain.

The five powers have so far not agreed on a clear timeline even though they agree to rid the world of nuclear weapons.

‘Now is the time for the delegations to be pragmatic and coalesce around solutions that will advance the interest of the whole community of nations,’ Ban said.

He called for adopting a document that will further strengthen nuclear non-proliferation and lead to nuclear disarmament.

The draft supports a conference in 2012 leading to a long-proposed nuclear-weapons free Middle East. The date was accepted by Arab governments for the first time, after years of pushing for the proposal.

The proposed 30-page draft was presented Monday night to NPT signatories and will likely be amended before Friday. It was drafted by Philippine Ambassador Libran Cabactulan, who chaired the review debate and tried to reflect the differences among participants.

Participants said the decision for a 2010 Middle East conference – under UN auspices – was by itself an achievement by the NPT signatories because it would bring together all nations in the Middle East, including Israel and Iran.

Israel has never admitted it has nuclear weapons, as alleged by Arab governments. The British Guardian newspaper published this week declassified South African documents claiming to show Israel offered to sell nuclear warheads to South Africa’s former apartheid regime.

The Middle East zone was first proposed at the NPT review conference in 1995. The draft calls for the appointment of a special envoy to lead talks and to report on progress between now and 2015, the next NPT review conference.

The 118 nations of the Non-Aligned Movement have been pressuring the NPT for a time-bound framework for nuclear disarmament, which runs counter to what the five nuclear powers want to do. Those powers can agree to the elimination of nuclear weapons but without a timeline.

The draft offers a plan of action, which included a reaffirmation of ‘the unequivocal undertaking of the nuclear weapon states to accomplish the total elimination of their nuclear arsenals leading to nuclear disarmament’.

The draft calls for further efforts ‘to verifiably reduce all types of nuclear weapons, deployed and non-deployed’, which would include tactical, non-strategic, weapons.

During closed-door debate, representatives of the five nuclear powers also opposed a separate international convention that would demand nuclear disarmament.

The draft calls for the UN secretary general to hold ‘open-ended high-level discussion to take stock and agree on a roadmap for the complete elimination of nuclear weapons, including by means of a universal legal instrument’.

Western governments attending the NPT conference also gave full support to the role of the International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA), in particular to enforcing a protocol which allows IAEA inspectors intrusive access to information and nuclear facilities of NPT signatories.

Non-aligned countries object to the intrusive access, and insist that the access is only a voluntary arrangement.

Three other countries – India, Pakistan and North Korea – have exploded nuclear devices. India and Pakistan never joined the NPT, while North Korea remains an NPT member although it has verbally withdrawn without filing official notice.

Categories: Uncategorized

Comments: Be the first to comment

Hoekstra: Obama Withholding Terrorism Intel from Congress

May 28, 2010

Hoekstra: Obama Withholding Terrorism Intel from Congress.

By: Jim Meyers

Rep. Pete Hoekstra tells Newsmax that the Obama administration is withholding critical information about terrorists that could be useful in preventing future attacks.

The Michigan legislator — the top Republican on the Permanent Select Committee on Intelligence — also says that if a successful attack does occur, responsibility will be on “the heads of the administration.”

And he insists there should be “consequences” for North Korea’s sinking of a South Korean naval vessel.

Rep. Hoekstra was first elected in 1992. He is not running for re-election in November and instead seeks the GOP nomination for governor in Michigan.
In an exclusive interview with Newsmax.TV, Hoekstra says: “All of us are very frustrated, Democrats and Republicans, with the lack of information sharing coming from this White House.

“They’re saying Justice is giving you everything they can. The operative words are ‘they can,’ because what the Justice Department is now throwing out is that the Christmas Day bombing, the attack at Fort Hood, the Times Square bombing, these are all now in the prosecutorial stage and we can’t give you information that may jeopardize the prosecution.

“So we’re learning very, very little about their connections to international organizations, how these things were funded, where the money came from — the types of things you would like to know to get a better understanding of each one of these attacks so that we can better enhance our intelligence capabilities to identify these threats earlier and stop them.

“I’m in the prevention business. I want these things prevented. I want these folks identified before they ever get to the United States, or before they can ever operationalize what they want to do. [Attorney General] Eric Holder and others are in the prosecutorial stage. That’s too late.”

Hoekstra charges that the administration has been withholding information on key terrorist threat Anwar al-Awlaki, an American-born Muslim cleric who moved to Yemen in 2004 and whose Internet sermons are believed to have helped inspire attacks on the U.S. He recently advocated the killing of American civilians in an al-Qaida video.

Hoekstra discloses that he traveled to Yemen on New Year’s Day, but the White House and Department of Defense contacted the American embassy there and instructed officials not to talk to Hoekstra about al-Awlaki.

“I don’t know why they did it,” Hoekstra says. “They still haven’t shared that information that I was looking for.

“That’s a mistake. Congress shouldn’t have to pull information out of the administration. It’s the administration’s job to keep us fully and currently informed on intelligence matters. That is the requirement of the law. This administration is not meeting those requirements.”

If a terrorist attack does succeed in the future “it will be on the heads of the administration because they do want to involve Congress in discussing the types of changes that might be necessary to keep America safe,” Hoekstra tells Newsmax.

“If they can’t give me the information as to what happened at Fort Hood, what happened on Christmas Day, what happened at Times Square, how can I work with them to give them better tools to keep American safe?

“That’s a discussion we need to be having. These homegrown terrorism threats are expanding. They are going to be more frequent. We’re going to have to modify and revise our intelligence gathering and our law enforcement procedures if we expect to keep America safe.”

Asked if he believes war could break out in Korea following the North’s sinking of a South Korean ship, Hoekstra responds:

“I sure hope not. That leads to all kinds of bad consequences throughout that part of the world. We’ve got enough struggles in the world right now without an all-out conflict on the Korean Peninsula.

“I don’t think China would want that to happen. I don’t think Russia would want that to happen. I’m not sure, however, that Russia and China have the influence over North Korea that if they wanted to do something like that, Russia and China could actually stop them.

“I do think we need to put North Korea back on the list of state sponsors of terrorism. I thought President Bush made a mistake when he took them off that list at the end of 2008. President Obama should put them back on the list.

“In some ways it’s a symbolic list, but sinking a warship is not a symbolic step. It was a real step by North Korea and there should be consequences to it.”

Hoekstra also says that Dennis Blair, who resigned as Director of National Intelligence under pressure from Obama, served as “something like a scapegoat” for the administration, and called the White House’s move a “wrong decision.”

And he charges that Iran is taking advantage of America’s “weakness and indecision” to continue its nuclear program.

“The consequences are that Iran has now had another year and a half to continue enriching uranium,” Hoekstra says.

“They’re a year and a half closer to having a nuclear weapon, and we’re a year and a half closer to Israel believing that perhaps the only way Iran will not get a nuclear weapon is if Israel takes unilateral action without the support of the United States. That would be a very ugly place for the Middle East and for the United States and Israel to find themselves.”

Categories: Uncategorized

Comments: Be the first to comment

Mosaic News – 5/26/10: World News From The Middle East

May 28, 2010

Link TV | Episode Transcript.

Ahmadinejad warns Russia over sanctions support

Al Jazeera TV, Qatar

Presenter, Female #1
Iranian President, Mahmud Ahmadinejad, criticized Russia’s latest stance against his country, describing it as “unacceptable.”Addressing a massive crowd in the city of Kerman, Ahmadinejad called on the Russian government to reconsider its position so that the Iranian people will not add Russia to the list of Tehran’s historical enemies. Our correspondent in Iran, Mohammad Hassan al-Bahrani, has the details in the following report.

Reporter, Male #1
It seems that Iran’s nuclear file entered a new escalation phase. It also seems that the US-led efforts to expand international sanctions on Iran are behind this tone of escalation, which has echoed in Iranian President, Mahmud Ahmadinejad’s address to the residents of Kerman Province.

Guest, Male #2 (Iranian President Mahmud Ahmadinejad)
I tell Mr. Obama to abandon the policies of pervious US administrations. The Tehran Declaration brings a historical and major opportunity that must be seized upon, if justice is really what you want to achieve. I doubt that the Iranian people will give you another opportunity. If you don’t seize this opportunity, you must know that the Iranian nation will cut your road short.

Reporter, Male #1
If Iranians are used to attacks by their political leaders against the US administration, they have not heard this tone of voice used against Russia. The Iranian president has sharply criticized the shift in Russia’s position toward Iran.

Guest, Male #2 (Iranian President, Mahmud Ahmadinejad)
Medvedev’s latest stance has confused the Iranian people. They don’t know whether Russia is still really their friend. It’s normal to expect from our friendly neighbor to stand by us in this critical time. Your current policy is unacceptable and must be reexamined.

Reporter, Male #1
Iranian sources saw in Ahmadinejad’s words a serious warning by Tehran directed at Moscow.

Guest, Male #3
This is a clear Iranian warning against Russia. I believe that the latest Russian stance is due to a sense of weakness felt by Russia in the face of US pressures. Anyhow, Russia needs Iran more than Iran needs it.

Reporter, Male #1
Amidst this strong Iranian warning directed at Russia, some are betting on a breakthrough in the Iranian nuclear crisis, which had started to ease up after the Tehran Declaration reached with Turkey and Brazil. However, with the new threats of sanctions looming on Iran, a political solution may not come that easily. Leading powers have threatened Iran with a first, a second, a third, and now a fourth round of sanctions over its nuclear program and uranium enrichment. Meanwhile, Iranians are saying: “Even if you take a unified position against us, you will not get what you wish for, and we will continue to enrich uranium as long as you continue to do so.” Mohammad Hassan al-Bahrani, al-Jazeera, Tehran.

Iran slams US response to Tehran Declaration

Press TV, Iran

Iran’s Foreign Minister Manouchehr Mottaki has critized Washington’s response to the Tehran Declaration. Mottaki singled out US Secretary of State Hilary Clinton’s remarks about the Declaration and described them as misleading. He has called the Tehran Declaration as a good opportunity for confidence building.

Amid regional tension, Israel holds massive defense drill

Al Arabiya TV, UAE

Presenter, Male # 1
The maneuvers conducted by Israel culminated with sirens, and Israelis heading to shelters and safe areas. The scenarios focused on rocket attacks launched from Lebanon, Syria and Iran on Israel’s strategic facilities and sites.

Reporter, Male # 2
As air raid sirens wailed across Israel, the Home Front Command’s military maneuvers reached their peak, and Israelis were asked to head to the shelters for 10 minutes, as the hypothetical war is entering its 18th day.

Guest, Male # 3 (Ehud Barak, Israel’s Defense Minister)
We seek to avoid war, and the maneuvers are taking place for the 4th year and will also be conducted next year. We want to be ready in the domains in which we need to be ready.

Reporter, Male # 2
Remarkably, Israel’s predictions, and probably its intelligence information, believe that there is a likelihood that its strategic and sensitive facilities might be targeted by missiles that are more precise than those that were used during the second Lebanon war. In the hypothetical war scenario, the Ministry of Defense was subjected to chemical missiles, which caused a large number of deaths and injuries, and a heavy financial toll. In addition, the Ashdod Port in the south and the Rambam Hospital in Haifa were shelled.

Guest, Male # 4 (Yaneer Golden, Home Front Command)
We are going to have all the different branches of the army around Israel participate. The maneuvers include all types of exercises, including weapons of mass destruction and chemical weapons.

Reporter, Male # 2
The exercises revealed one weak point: Israel’s low level of preparedness to face a chemical or biological attack. Only 5 percent of Israelis have received gas masks, but their participation in the maneuvers was larger than that of previous years because of the fear that Israel might attack Iran, which could trigger a regional war in which the Home Front Command is placed on the frontlines. Although Israel’s attempts to reassure that the military maneuvers are routine and defensive, it is clear that it is basing its actions on intelligence information and could be sending a double message, inside and outside the country, that Israel is ready for any future war. Ziad Halabi, al-Arabiya, Tel Aviv.

Hezbollah mobilizes on border in response to Israel drill

IBA TV, Israel

Hezbollah has mobilized its forces inside Lebanon; they claim this is in response to Israel’s civil defense drill that is taking place this week. Also, Syria has for months, been saying that Israel is planning to attack Syria.

Hezbollah leader says Israel ‘continues its ideology of racism, arrogance’

Press TV, Iran

Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah said that “for this reason, there is something which we must tell the Israelis, and there is something that we must not tell the Israelis. And be sure, that what we must not tell the Israelis, I will not say it and nobody must say it. It will be a surprise in any future war.”

Categories: Uncategorized

Comments: Be the first to comment

: WH Counterterror advisor: Jihad a ‘legitimate tenet’ of Islam

May 28, 2010

American Thinker Blog: WH Counterterror advisor: Jihad a ‘legitimate tenet’ of Islam.

I know what he was trying to say; that there are some schools of Islamic thought that defines “jihad” as unarmed “struggle” by the pious Muslim against his own weaknesses.

So what?

That’s not how our enemies describe Jihad. The Islamists combine religious fervor with a fanatical political ideology that instructs them to kill those who won’t submit. It really is that simple and the idea that we have top officials (Brennan isn’t the only one who holds this view) in the Obama White House who pretend that Islamists don’t believe what they actually believe is worse than self-delusion; it is bordering on criminal negligence:

The president’s top counterterrorism adviser on Wednesday called jihad a “legitimate tenet of Islam,” arguing that the term “jihadists” should not be used to describe America’s enemies.

During a speech at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, John Brennan described violent extremists as victims of “political, economic and social forces,” but said that those plotting attacks on the United States should not be described in “religious terms.”

He repeated the administration argument that the enemy is not “terrorism,” because terrorism is a “tactic,” and not terror, because terror is a “state of mind” — though Brennan’s title, deputy national security adviser for counterterrorism and homeland security, includes the word “terrorism” in it. But then Brennan said that the word “jihad” should not be applied either.

“Nor do we describe our enemy as ‘jihadists’ or ‘Islamists’ because jihad is a holy struggle, a legitimate tenet of Islam, meaning to purify oneself or one’s community, and there is nothing holy or legitimate or Islamic about murdering innocent men, women and children,” Brennan said.

Please note in the second paragraph above where Brennan describes violent extremists as “victims.” What does that make the targets of their fanaticism? Do we have victim on victim crime? Or perhaps the jihadists targets had it coming? You cannot have a terrorist attack without someone being at fault. And if Brennan is going to excuse the jihadists because they are suffering oppression or something, then he must believe that those who die horribly in those attacks deserved it.

This is the same naive fool who wants to look for and promote Hezb’allah “moderates.” Michael Totten, who has forgotten more about Hezb’allah than this fool will ever learn, applies the necessary take down:

There are no moderates within Hezbollah, at least not any who stand a chance of changing Hezbollah’s behavior. Sure, the terrorist militia has sent a handful of its members to parliament, as Brennan says, and once in a while they sound more reasonable than its secretary-general, Hassan Nasrallah, but these people are employees. They don’t make policy.

If you want to catch a glimpse of Hezbollah’s org chart, just rent a car in Beirut and drive south. You’ll see billboards and posters all over the place in the areas Hezbollah controls. Some show the portraits of “martyrs” killed in battle with Israel. Others show the mug shots of Hezbollah’s leadership, most prominently Nasrallah and his deceased military commander, truck bomber, and airplane hijacker Imad Mugniyeh. Alongside the pictures of Hezbollah’s leaders, you’ll also see Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini and Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, the two “supreme guides” of the Islamic Republic regime in Iran.

Sun Tzu famously made the first rule of war “Know your enemy.” Brennan has taken that adage a step further. He is pretending there is no enemy, no war – only victims who who need us to address the “root causes” of their fanaticism.

I am not confident that we will escape the next three years without a massive terrorist attack. At this level of denial comes extreme danger. Seeing the enemy as potential welfare customers will not win any battles and will probably get a lot of innocent people killed.

Categories: Uncategorized

Comments: Be the first to comment

First step toward last resort: No case to attack Iran before trying sanctions.

May 28, 2010

First step toward last resort: No case to attack Iran before trying sanctions..

The United States has at least two reasons for trying everything short of preemptive attack to keep Iran from obtaining a nuclear weapon. Sanctions might work, in the unlikely event that Iran’s leaders develop more than a fleeting case of rational thinking. If sanctions don’t work, the U.S. – as was not the case before invading Iraq – will have more international support for that last resort.

Such a strategy, however, doesn’t mean letting Iran play us and the United Nations for chumps. Iran was trying to do that when, to avoid a fourth round of U.N. sanctions, the country suddenly announced a deal last week with Turkey and Brazil to export 2,640 pounds of low-enriched uranium and receive, in return, fuel rods suitable for use in a medical research reactor but not suitable for use in a nuclear weapon.

President Obama and Secretary of State Hillary Clinton quickly and correctly called that deal a sham. Though the uranium-out/fuel-back model once could have halted Iran’s drive to produce the enriched uranium necessary for making bombs, that strategy works only if Iran sends away most of its enriched uranium and stops enriching more. Under the Turkey/Brazil deal, Iran would give up only half its enriched uranium and didn’t promise to stop producing it. By most estimates, the deal would leave Iran with enough enriched uranium to produce at least one bomb.

One day after Turkey and Brazil declared themselves to be Iran’s enablers, the Obama administration announced that China and Russia – surprisingly – have said that they are open to economic sanctions against Iran. Mr. Obama has courted them because Russia is Iran’s largest trading partner and China buys lots of Iranian oil. If they don’t renege, their agreement clears the way for the five permanent members of the UN Security Council to approve sanctions. Until Dec. 31, Turkey and Brazil are two of the council’s 10 non-permanent members, which explains Iran’s outreach to them.

Proposed sanctions include a tighter weapons embargo, the right to search shipments to Iran and a list of companies and individuals barred from trade. Still, they’re seen as fairly weak. Even though some companies may impose tougher sanctions, Iran still might be able to cheat. But sanctions could delay the day when Iran gets too close to nuclear capability for the West to ignore. Israel has bombed Iraq and Syria to cut off nuclear development. Something like that, perhaps carried out by the United States or a group of allies, could be necessary again.

If sanctions don’t end Iran’s nuclear ambitions, they at least would be a step – if Iran gets too close to building a bomb – toward proving that armed intervention is the only remaining option to avoiding a Middle East nuclear arms race

Categories: Uncategorized

Comments: Be the first to comment

Newer Entries »
My Father joined me on my warship for the ceremony marking the withdrawl of Israeli forces from the Sinai after the peace agreement with Egypt.

Please help “A Sclerotic Goes to War” stay online till the war ends.

Pages

  • Home
  • About the site
  • Books By Joseph Wouk
  • Video Reports – Gaza
  • Video Reports – Iran

Recent Posts

  • From ‘Atoms for Peace’ to Witkoff: A history of Iran’s nuke program, and efforts to stop it April 15, 2025
  • Top Iranian officials told Khamenei to allow US nuke talks or risk fall of regime – NYT April 14, 2025
  • Trump: Israel would ‘be the leader’ of strike on Iran if nuclear talks fall apart April 14, 2025
  • Netanyahu Says Iran Deal Must Include Blowing Up and Dismantling Nuclear Sites April 14, 2025
  • Preparations Underway To Strike Iran March 27, 2025
  • Nasrallah’s children say he cried after pager attack and fell into depression March 7, 2025
  • Iran’s uranium stockpile surges, IAEA warns of nuclear weapon threat – The Jerusalem Post March 3, 2025
  • BREAKING: Iran PANICS Fearing Immediate Israel-US Attack On Nuclear Facilities | TBN Israel – YouTube February 27, 2025
  • Israel sees opening for strikes on Iranian nuclear sites: US intelligence February 25, 2025
  • Benjamin Netanyahu and Marco Rubio affirm plans on Iran, Gaza – Israel News – The Jerusalem Post February 16, 2025
  • Netanyahu “Iran is COLLAPSING before the Entire World…” December 13, 2024
  • ASSAD’S DOWNFALL Israel’s opportunity to THINK BIG Caroline Glick December 9, 2024
  • Peace with Syria: The Ultimate Middle East Reset Button December 8, 2024
  • Israeli PM Netanyahu warns Syria after ‘fall’ of Assad | LiveNOW from FOX December 8, 2024
  • What will be the regional implications of the fall of Assad? December 8, 2024
  • As Iran Falls, Who Will Rise in the Middle East w David Wurmser – The Caroline Glick Show December 4, 2024
  • Israel hit nuke weapons research site in Iran last month, set back program — report November 19, 2024
  • Why Trump can reset the Middle East conflict November 13, 2024
  • Israel boosts defense over Iran threats before Donald Trump’s return November 11, 2024
  • Donald Trump confirms Elise Stefanik US ambassador to UN role November 11, 2024
  • IRGC operative charged in plot to assassinate Trump, Jewish targets in US November 11, 2024
  • ‘New strategy’: How Israel could take down Iran and its proxies November 4, 2024
  • Hezbollah beginning to crack: Wave of desertions threatens Lebanese terror group – report October 31, 2024
  • Israel FIRES back at Iran! Was that it? | Caroline Glick In-Focus October 28, 2024
  • The Existence Of Israel’s Secret Stealth Drone Should Come As No Surprise October 28, 2024

Recent Comments

  • overlord on Netanyahu “Iran is COLLAPSING before the Entire World…”
  • CARLOS LIZARRAGA on From ‘Atoms for Peace’ to Witkoff: A history of Iran’s nuke program, and efforts to stop it
  • Louisiana Steve on Preparations Underway To Strike Iran
  • Joseph Wouk on Netanyahu “Iran is COLLAPSING before the Entire World…”
  • Overlord on Netanyahu “Iran is COLLAPSING before the Entire World…”
  • Calvin Fuller on Israel’s regional security challenges – Jerusalem Studio 513 
  • Pete Conde on Israel hit nuke weapons research site in Iran last month, set back program — report
  • budfundi on Donald Trump confirms Elise Stefanik US ambassador to UN role
  • Louisiana Steve on Hezbollah beginning to crack: Wave of desertions threatens Lebanese terror group – report
  • budfundi on Hezbollah operatives were duped into holding pagers with 2 hands, causing worse injuries
  • Overlord on Israel’s Netanyahu Addresses Iranian People In Social Media Post Amidst Rising Tensions
  • Overlord on Israel has just now announced that Nasralla has been ELIMINATED!
  • Overlord on Israel has just now announced that Nasralla has been ELIMINATED!
  • zoltinformation on Israel has just now announced that Nasralla has been ELIMINATED!
  • CARLOS LIZARRAGA on How the Israel Air Force could bring Iran to its knees – analysis

External Links

  • Google News “Israel attack Iran”
  • News: JewPi.com
  • Debka File
  • Jerusalem Post
  • Haaretz Israel News
  • YNet Israel News
  • Al Arabiya

Archives

May 2010
S M T W T F S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
3031  
« Apr   Jun »

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 441 other subscribers

A Sclerotic Goes to War

  • RSS - Posts

  • anneinpt's avatar anneinpt
    • And more on Antisemitism on the British Left
    • The not-so-tamim Tamimi family of Ahed Tamimi
    • BDS banned! – Hear them whine
    • The West’s shameful response to the Iran protests
    • Updated: Mordechai Kedar destroys Muslim claims to Jerusalem on Al-Jazeera TV – full video with English subtitles
  • artaxes's avatar artaxes
    • Prepare for a bad Iran deal
    • Hezbollah reorganizes ranks in light of leaks
    • Off Topic: Admiral Warns that Risk of Nuclear Conflict Is Growing
    • Kerry Lauds Nonexistent Iranian Fatwa Banning Nuclear Weapons – MEMRI
    • War Across the Borders
  • danmillerinpanama's avatar danmillerinpanama
    • Video: TOM FITTON: “PICK YOUR POISON” – Obama Abused Either Clinton or Russia FBI Investigation
    • Sharyl Attkisson on FISA Surveillance Abuses.
    • Kurdish militia repels Turkish Afrin invasion amid continuing Turkish air blitz
    • Cartoons and Video of the Day
    • Former FBI Director James Comey to teach ethical leadership class
  • davidking1530's avatar davidking1530
    • From ‘Atoms for Peace’ to Witkoff: A history of Iran’s nuke program, and efforts to stop it
    • Top Iranian officials told Khamenei to allow US nuke talks or risk fall of regime – NYT
    • Trump: Israel would ‘be the leader’ of strike on Iran if nuclear talks fall apart
    • Netanyahu Says Iran Deal Must Include Blowing Up and Dismantling Nuclear Sites
    • Nasrallah’s children say he cried after pager attack and fell into depression
  • Peter Hofman's avatar Peter Hofman
    • A light in the darkness
    • Joe Biden: Israel’s Fake ‘Friend’
    • Happy Passover! Chag Pesach Sameach
    • HAMAS LEADER: “If Gazans start dying from the China Virus because we run out of ventilators, we will make sure that six million Israelis are unable to breathe”
    • NETANYAHU: WE WILL HAVE NO CHOICE BUT START MILITARY CAMPAIGN IN GAZA
  • Joseph Wouk's avatar Joseph Wouk
    • Preparations Underway To Strike Iran
    • Iran’s uranium stockpile surges, IAEA warns of nuclear weapon threat – The Jerusalem Post
    • BREAKING: Iran PANICS Fearing Immediate Israel-US Attack On Nuclear Facilities | TBN Israel – YouTube
    • Benjamin Netanyahu and Marco Rubio affirm plans on Iran, Gaza – Israel News – The Jerusalem Post
    • Netanyahu “Iran is COLLAPSING before the Entire World…”
  • Peter's avatar Peter
    • OFF TOPIC: America’s Soldiers Singing “Days of Elijah”
    • Armed Shi’ite rebels push into Yemen’s capital
    • Islamic State seizes villages in Syria
    • Police: Random beheading plot ‘disrupted’
    • The Turkish AK Party and the Islamic State
  • Louisiana Steve's avatar Louisiana Steve
    • Justice Department charges Iranian hackers with attacks on US cities, companies
    • PUTIN TO ISRAEL, U.S.: LOOSEN SANCTIONS IN EXCHANGE FOR IRAN LEAVING SYRIA
    • Mossad said to thwart Hezbollah terror plot against Jewish targets in Argentina
    • Trump Ends $1.3 Billion Payments To Pakistan: “I Ended It Because They Don’t Do Anything For Us”
    • Life in Israel under the shadow of Hamas’s rockets

Blog at WordPress.com.

  • Subscribe Subscribed
    • WarSclerotic
    • Join 369 other subscribers
    • Already have a WordPress.com account? Log in now.
    • WarSclerotic
    • Subscribe Subscribed
    • Sign up
    • Log in
    • Report this content
    • View site in Reader
    • Manage subscriptions
    • Collapse this bar