Countering contemptuous Palestinians

Countering contemptuous Palestinians, Israel Hayom, David M. Weinberg, July 28, 2017

(In the present environment, “two state solution” would a precursor to the death of Israel. — DM)

Israel should unsheathe its sovereign power and put the extremists down; decisive action that one day might allow for Palestinian moderates to emerge.


The Palestinian Authority and its fiendish intra-Palestinian Islamic rivals seem hellbent on brinkmanship; on being belligerent adversaries with escalating, maximalist demands of Israel.

They really think they can roll Israel back by recourse to street brawls and international courts; by browbeating Israel through aggression, isolation and criminalization; by demonizing Israel with outrageous lies like “Al-Aqsa is in danger.” They think they can conduct guerilla and diplomatic warfare against Israel with impunity.

It’s time to disabuse Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas and these gangs of such delusion, through resolute Israeli action.

The holy war over the Temple Mount that Abbas is promoting tells Israelis that Palestinian society has gone crazy-radical-rogue Islamic — just like much of the Arab Middle East. This spells the end of the two-state solution as Israelis (and most Western policymakers) understood it. Because the one thing that Israel absolutely cannot countenance is the emergence of a madcap Islamic caliphate in Jerusalem and Judea and Samaria.

Sinai-stan, Hamas-stan, Hezbollah-stan, and Syria-stan already have emerged on Israel’s southern and northern borders. This is more than enough for Israel to handle. A Pales-stan on Israel’s eastern border would be unbearable. Israel can’t and won’t let it rise.

The only Palestinian state in the West Bank that Israelis ever contemplated was a mature entity willing to reconcile ideologically with Israel, leading to the reasonable sharing of land, airspace, natural resources, and historical and religious sites.

The sharing includes the Temple Mount. Indeed, for there to be peace, Jewish prayer would have to be facilitated on the Temple Mount, alongside the prayers of other faith-traditions.

Alas, Abbas has made it clear that the Palestinian national movement is far from understanding this.

The only Palestinian state that Israelis ever envisioned would not threaten Israel’s security, obviously. This means that it would be truly demilitarized with Israeli supervision on all borders and at all holy places. It would not form hostile foreign alliances or allow radical Islamic groups to dictate the internal agenda. It would not rev up violent insurrection when it has a difference of opinion about management of a city or holy site.

Alas, Abbas has made it clear that the Palestinian national movement is far from accepting this.

The only Palestinian state that Israelis ever thought of tolerating in Judea, Samaria and Gaza would declare a permanent end to the conflict and all claims against Israel. This means recognizing Israel as the nation-state of the Jewish people and recognizing ancient Jerusalem as its capital. It means renouncing the so-called right of refugee return, and inculcating respect, not anti-Semitism, on Palestinians airwaves and in Palestinian schools.

Alas, Abbas has made it clear that the Palestinian national movement is far from internalizing this.

On the contrary, Abbas has made it clear that the Palestinian liberation movement will never recognize Israel as a Jewish state nor forgo refugee return. In other words, he wants his state, but without an end to the conflict. He seems to want a Palestinian state to continue the conflict.

Professor Ahmad Khalidi, a Palestinian ideologue close to Abbas, scorns the two-state solution as a “sovereign cage.” “The concept of Palestinian statehood is nothing but a punitive construct devised by our worst enemies — the United States and Israel — to constrain Palestinian aspirations and territorial ambitions,” he has written.

Until now, Israeli governments have sought to co-opt Palestinian leaders into peace and to mollify Palestinian masses through compromise and concession, including the provision of Israeli money, guns, water, electricity and many aspects of national sovereignty.

This could have been a path to enhanced Palestinian national power in cooperation with Israel. But the kleptocratic Palestinian Authority has pocketed these goodies without showing any true willingness to meet Israeli needs and expectations.

As a result, tactical Israeli restraint, like the decision to retreat from justified security measures at the Temple Mount, comes off as capitulation to Palestinian terrorism. It reinforces the rejectionist and triumphalist Palestinian narrative. It looks and smells like appeasement.

Winston Churchill warned that “an appeaser is one who feeds a crocodile, hoping it will eat him last.” So it’s time for a different strategy. Palestinian overreach and superciliousness should be countered by strong Israeli and international countermeasures.

Palestinian leadership must be disabused of the notion that it can drive Israel off the Temple Mount and out of east Jerusalem by violence, or coerce Israel into withdrawals by appealing to international tribunals.

This will require perseverance and the flexing of muscle.

To begin with, Israel can stop doing favors for the Palestinian Authority like absorbing its mushrooming debt for electricity and fuel, or selling it water at discount prices. Then Israel should stop facilitating the business interests of Abbas’ cronies, whose cartels control the Palestinian economy. The international donor community, too, might usefully rethink the huge sums of cash it pours into Abbas’ coffers every year.

Then Israel can and should revoke the VIP permits that allow Abbas and his ministers to fly in and out of Ben-Gurion International Airport on their luxury private jets. Let them beg King Abdullah in Amman for travel privileges.

Simultaneously, Israel should arrest the activities in east Jerusalem of rabble rousers like Sheikh Ekrima Sa’id Sabri, the former the grand mufti of Jerusalem and the lead agent in the city for Erdogan’s Turkey and the Moslem Brotherhood; Sheikh Issam Amira, the lead agent in the city for the Islamic Liberation Party (Hizb ut-Tahrir); and Abbas’ handpicked henchmen, the intemperate Grand Mufti Muhammad Ahmad Hussein and the fanatic former chief justice of the PA’s religious court, Sheikh Tayseer Al-Tamimi.

Their sermons, “charitable” enterprises and educational programs glorify terrorists and explicitly call for violent resistance to Israel. Their networks (along with Fatah social media) also are the source for the libel that Al-Aqsa mosque is at risk.

It’s also not too hard to arrest 2,000 of their key street activists — those leading the riots in the city.

Israel should unsheathe its sovereign power and put the extremists down; decisive action that one day might allow for Palestinian moderates to emerge.

David M. Weinberg ( is director of public affairs at the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies.

Explore posts in the same categories: Abbas, Israel - Jewish state, Israeli concessions to Palestinians, Israeli security, Palestinian Authority, Palestinian incitement, Palestinian Islamists, Palestinian right of return, Palestinian terrorists, Palestinians and Jews, Peace process, Two state solution

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , ,

You can skip to the end and leave a response. Pinging is currently not allowed.

4 Comments on “Countering contemptuous Palestinians”

  1. John Prophet Says:



    on a distant shore,

    my minds eye

    floats upon.

    Swirling thought

    upon swirling thought

    do my reflections grow.

    Infinite realms

    offer fertile grounds

    to burrow through.


    of realities

    the minds eye sees

    one as real as them all.

    Traveling through oceans

    of ethereal thought,

    swimming through the

    infinite, the possibilities

    the minds eye can see.

    Rays of thought

    pass thru

    the the mind

    as rays of light do too.

    Reflections on the infinite

    my minds eye wanders thru.


    what I see,

    nearly impossible to do.

    Impressions of possibilities

    that boil up,

    reaching out.

    Infinite possibilities

    bringing closer,

    I aim to do.

    Back I light

    on familiar ground

    having made my recent voyage

    Till next I float once again

    through the clouds of infinitely.

    Once again

    my mind takes flight.


    at all there is to see.


    through different times

    and realities.


    things as perhaps

    they might be.

    Different story lines

    as far
    as any mind’s eye

    can see.

    Dizzying vistas

    unfathomable to me,

    fit for only the

    creator to see.
    Different stories

    of me float by.

    back to whence I came.

    Back, nauseous

    from the flight

    so unsettling the

    experience be.

    though how finite

    our vision

    with the limited

    vista that we can see.

    should we truly be

    with the “truths”

    as fact expounded

    in our limited

    finite reality.

    • John Propher Says:

      We And A Fish

      A speck of blue

      in the limitless black.
      The infinite

      of existence.
      All we know

      so finite.
      Like a fish

      in an aquarium

      whose universe

      consists of
      the aquarium

      and what little is observable

      in the immediate surrounding.
      The fish has not concept

      of what’s down the hall,
      in the next room,

      what’s upstairs,

      what’s down the street,
      what’s in the next town,

      next country

      or on the moon.
      Like the fish,

      we see our world

      and what our telescopes

      Like the fish

      we know nothing

      about what’s beyond

      our vision.
      What then in fact,

      do we really

      know at all?

      • John Propher Says:


        We Live in


        With our lives

        we scurry around

        like little ants.

        We run

        to the store.

        We run

        to the game.

        We run

        to pick up the children.

        We run to our jobs.

        Every day pretty

        much like the rest.

        Some hold out

        their chest

        as if they’re


        Others think

        they rule the world,

        but it’s just a

        tiny terrarium.

  2. wingate Says:

    Friends – why do we Play the game of Israels enemies? Why do we join the talk about the socalled ”palestinians” ? There is no and never was a palestinian people ! Its the lie of our times – invented by the archterrorist arafat, an egyptian ! The goal of the lie ? To rob the historical Land of Israel from its rightful owners – the Jews – to finish Hitlers job !
    The filistines of Biblical times originated from Crete and have nothing to do with those who Call themselves ”palestinians”.
    Joining the socalled ”palestinians ” means cursing /fighting Israel !
    Cursing / fighting Israel will bring the curse of the Almighty God of Israel on those who do
    So !
    So if you love yourself / your nation – bless Israel and stop supporting the socalled ”palestinians ” who are actually present time Nazis who want to destroy the people of Israel !

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: