Israel no longer certain Obama would ever use force against Iran, Likud MK indicates

Israel no longer certain Obama would ever use force against Iran, Likud MK indicates | The Times of Israel.

Tzachi Hanegbi: In his UN speech, PM was telling Iran that Israel will take action ‘even if the Americans will be prevented from acting against you’

October 2, 2013, 7:43 pm
Tzachi Hanegbi (right) and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (photo credit: Miriam Alster/Flash90)

Tzachi Hanegbi (right) and Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu (photo credit: Miriam Alster/Flash90)

NEW YORK — Israel is no longer certain that the Obama administration would employ military force even as a last resort to thwart Iran attaining nuclear weapons, a senior colleague of Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu indicated for the first time.

That new uncertainty was a relatively recent development, Tzachi Hanegbi, a Likud Knesset member and former cabinet minister, further indicated. The turning point was America’s response to the crisis over the alleged use of chemical weapons by Syria’s Assad regime in late August. And it explained why Netanyahu, in his speech at the UN General Assembly, felt the imperative to warn the Iranians that Israel would act on its own if necessary.

Speaking to The Times of Israel in New York in the wake of Netanyahu’s speech to the UN General Assembly on Tuesday, Hanegbi said “the most dramatic part” of the prime minister’s address was the passage in which he warned, “Israel will not allow Iran to get nuclear weapons. If Israel is forced to stand alone, Israel will stand alone.”

Why was this so dramatic, Hanegbi asked rhetorically? “Because it marked the first time it was said in public, and not behind closed doors, that Israel will act even if stands alone.”

“What does that mean, to ‘stand alone,’” he asked, again rhetorically? “After all, we didn’t expect the world to act. But our expectation was and remains that the United States — if the negotiations do indeed fail — would employ the military option which the president has said several times is not removed from the table. But we saw recently that even if the president has a clear and unequivocal position, as in the Syrian case, sometimes all kinds of constraints are placed upon him that are not under his control, like the position of Congress or American public opinion. (President Barack Obama initially threatened punitive military action for the Assad regime’s August 21 alleged chemical weapons attack, later said he would consult Congress, and ultimately accepted a Russian-instigated diplomatic initiative.)

“Therefore,” Hanegbi went on, “the prime minister essentially is telling the Iranians: ‘Do not delude yourselves. Even if the Americans will be prevented from acting against you, we will know how to defend ourselves, with our own forces.’”

Asked whether, rhetoric aside, Israel could actually strike at Iran when the US president was engaged with Tehran in a diplomatic effort to resolve the nuclear crisis, Hanegbi dismissed such a scenario. “The non-diplomatic option will only become applicable once it is clear that the diplomatic option failed,” he said. “Since the American president clarified what he expects in the diplomatic realm, it is clear that if this doesn’t work, he couldn’t come and complain to any other player.”

Hwoever, a senior official in the prime minister’s delegation to the US told The Times of Israel Wednesday that a preemptive Israeli strike against Iranian nuclear facilities remains a viable option even while Washington is engaged in a diplomatic process with Tehran.

“The prime minister was very clear about it. He said that that option is still on the table,” said the official, who spoke on condition of anonymity. “It is not the preferred option, as we prefer a successful solution to the crisis through diplomatic means, but it’s always on the table.”

In his comments to The Times of Israel, Hanegbi added that “the prime minister’s position represents the State of Israel, and he is very skeptical about Iran’s willingness to give up on a dream they have tried to advance for more than 15 years.”

Hanegbi, who is considered close to the prime minister, also noted that Netanyahu’s speech included a “hardening of positions” regarding Jerusalem’s demands of Iran, as for the first time he required that Iran close its uranium enrichment plant in Natanz, as well as its facilities at Qom and Arak.

Any “meaningful” diplomatic solution to the Iranian nuclear standoff would require four steps, Netanyahu told the UN: “First, cease all uranium enrichment… Second, remove from Iran’s territory the stockpiles of enriched uranium. Third, dismantle the infrastructure for nuclear breakout capability, including the underground facility at Qom and the advanced centrifuges in Natanz. And, four, stop all work at the heavy water reactor in Arak aimed at the production of plutonium.”

Previously, his four stated conditions had included closure of the Qom and Arak facilities, but Tuesday’s speech for the first time included the demand to close Natanz as well. “Apparently, what can be done in Qom can also be done in all other facilities,” said Hanegbi.

Netanyahu on Wednesday morning spoke to presidents and directors of leading media companies, staffers said. In his counter-Rouhani media blitz, he was later giving interviews to NBC, CBS and Univision (Spanish). On Thursday, he was to speak to CNN, ABC, and others, before heading home.

Explore posts in the same categories: Uncategorized

5 Comments on “Israel no longer certain Obama would ever use force against Iran, Likud MK indicates”

  1. Joop Klepzeiker's avatar Joop Klepzeiker Says:

    This four stated condition will never be accepted by iran, the usa know it the eu know en russia know it.

    iran is untouchable according the brzezinski doctrine

    So what is the purpose of this fake trying for a diplomatic solution .

    Yep you got it Israel have to act on his one and will act, but that is exact according the plan and give a perfect opportunity to get Israel under full control of the USA. a confrontation whit the USA is in mine opinion not impossible.

  2. Norm's avatar Norm Says:

    Michele will not allow her husband to have a legacy of a wartime president. She will have him stall, appease, and bluster without regard to what position they leave the United States to the next president. Additionally, if the lucky situation should arise that we find ourselves in such economic and political chaos that would allow Barack to stay in office by emergency decree….that would even be better.

  3. Smiley's avatar Smiley Says:

    Hi Louisiana Steve, all we can say is that whatever you post on this site or other sites, please take into consideration that it is a public site and anyone can read whatever we post.

    Security wise, please contact JW and he can help you with that.

    We agree with you, that our families come first, and we have to and need to protect our families.

    Having said that, you and your family are quite safe, and you have more to worry about the American government spying on you, as you probably read or might have heard the NSA is filtering hundreds of millions emails everyday from the US and the world for various things. It is againts the US constitution that they are doing this, but they make new laws or loop holes to be able to get away with it.

    So if your not emailing about any criminal actions or thoughts, then you will be fine.

    As for posting on JW blog, no one is going to bother you, unless you were posting information about assassination plans of an Iranian agent, government official, or any other countries agents or government officials, but those things wouldnt be posted here, it would be on secure apparatuses and methods that we wouldnt have access to.

    We try to be careful not to post anything concerning military maneuvers or capabilities, as the hostile Obama administration leaked Israeli military ideas, that benefited Iran, which is why it is hard for many to believe the Obama administration about anything they say, and why it is harmful for Israel to keep waiting for the US and Iranian negotiations, as things keep getting worse and worse for Israeli security.

    Israel might win the war againts Iran and its proxies, but if 1 or 2 nuclear devices such as nuclear suicide bombers get in, etc, and Israel gets a third degree burn to 90 % of it, it might have survived but it might be uninhabitable even in the 10% left.

    Thats why we hope Bibi takes action as soon as possible, because John the Prophet blogger is correct, sadly it is really late to take action now, even if some people dont want to hear it.

    Its important that Israel takes military action as soon as possible, to minimize the damage it will get, and the longer it takes to the worse damage it will get, as a third degree burn to 90% of it, it might have survived but it might be uninhabitable even in the 10% left.

    You can also google info about how to track blog postings or tracking emails, but we think JW might be able to help you with that.

    Also many postings ago, I think Joop and Luis, and maybe others were posting info how to create safe emailing methods and internet connections, and internet filtering, etc.

    Please could anyone on this site advise Louisiana Steve about how to create safe emailing methods and internet connections, and internet filtering, etc.

    Thank you, Smiley.

    • Louisiana Steve's avatar Louisiana Steve Says:

      Thanks for the good words, Smiley. Up to now, I didn’t think much about the need for ‘safe’ communications.

      As you’ve probably seen, I enjoy expressing my opinion on the rapidly changing situation in the Mideast in a respectful and concise manner. I certainly wouldn’t express anything that could or would result in harm to anyone.

      My biggest concern is that of Israel’s safety and equally so, the plight of our American soldiers wounded or killed in the Mideast struggle against radical Islam. If that constitutes espionage, then I’m guilty as hell.

      No need for secure communications here. Still, I look forward to a little feedback from JW concerning this matter. Thanks again.

      • Louisiana Steve's avatar Louisiana Steve Says:

        “Paranoia strikes deep
        Into your life it will creep
        It starts when you’re always afraid
        You step out of line, the man come and take you away
        We better stop, hey, what’s that sound
        Everybody look what’s going down…”

        -Buffalo Springfield – Somethings Happening Here


Leave a reply to Smiley Cancel reply